跳到正文
The Guardian·· 6 小時前精選推薦指數90.48

‘Well-known’ man fails in legal attempt to block Guardian and ITN publishing sexual allegations

“知名”男子試圖阻止《衛報》與ITN發布性行為不當指控,法律訴訟失敗

導讀

Anonymity of individual, whose lawyers had sought injunction citing suicide risk, remains in place subject to any appeal A “well-known individual” has failed in his attempt to stop two media organisations from publishing allegations of inappropriate sexual activities towards young women, the high court has ruled. The legal team for the anonymous individual, known in court only as PPT, had claimed he was “highly likely” to attempt suicide if the Guardian and ITN published the allegations, which he denies. Continue reading...

英國高等法院裁定,媒體有權發布對一名匿名知名人士的不當性行為指控,其自殺風險應由醫療機構而非法院通過禁令來應對。判決同時強調,案件審理的只是能否發布,而非指控是否屬實。

會員

精讀全文屬於會員

免費帳號每天可以讀 10 篇文庫文章,每天換一批,這 10 篇的正文、詞匯和 PDF 導出都能用。訂閱會員後,下面的內容全部打開。

¥9.9 / 月

推薦理由

判決書式報道,適合練法律論證的因果鏈與權利權衡:先定位法官承認了什麼(自殺風險會顯著上升),再看他為何仍駁回禁令(責任在精神健康服務機構)。注意第2、3、8條公約權利與言論自由之間的比較結構,以及“發布是否屬實不在本案範圍”這一限定,是推斷題和作者態度題的好材料。

來源:The Guardian · theguardian.com